ONA Successfully Challenges Arbitration Decision in Divisional Court

News/
25 July 2019
Share
Share with your friends and colleagues
Pick one or more destinations:

In ONA v Cambridge Memorial Hospital and Arbitrator Dana Randall, the Divisional Court set aside an arbitration award involving a nurse suffering substance dependency whose employment was terminated for misappropriating narcotics. Despite the arbitrator finding the nurse had a disability (i.e. substance dependency) and that "but for" her condition, she would not have engaged in the misconduct that led to her dismissal, the arbitrator still found the termination to be just.

The Court rejected the arbitrator's decision, holding:

(1) Once an individual establishes a nexus between the substance dependency and the misconduct, there is a prima facie evidence of discrimination. The prima facie discrimination test, as settled by the Supreme Court of Canada in Stewart v Elk Valley Coal Corp, requires the complainant to only establish:

i. that they have a characteristic that is protected from discrimination under the Human Rights Code;

ii. that they have experienced an adverse impact; and

iii. that the protected characteristic was a factor in the adverse impact.

 (2) The arbitrator incorrectly focused on the concept of "compulsion", or lack thereof, on the part of the nurse. The arbitrator's finding also incorrectly focused on the concept of "general deterrence". The Court found that arbitrators cannot add such additional words or concepts to the test for prima facie discrimination, which Elk Valley made clear are not part of the test.

(3) Labour arbitrators have developed special expertise in the area of human rights discrimination, and while a presumption of reasonableness was found to apply here, the arbitrator's decision was unreasonable and did not "fall within a range of possible, acceptable outcomes".

Congratulations to ONA, which was represented by Kate Hughes, Danielle Bisnar and Tyler Boggs.

Recent News

News/29 November 2021

Update on Canada Labour Code Changes since November 2019

Update on Canada Labour Code Changes Since November 2019 Read More
News/29 November 2021

UPDATE to Recent Changes to Canada Labour Code November 2019

UPDATE to Recent Changes to Canada Labour Code November 2019 Read More
News/19 November 2021

Grassy Narrows takes Ontario to court for failure to consult and obtain consent on mining exploration permits

Grassy Narrows First Nation launched a legal action against Ontario for its failure to consult Grassy Narrows on nine mining exploration permits betwe... Read More