Employment Law and Litigation

The courts can be a powerful tool for workers and organizations seeking to enforce their legal rights. At Cavalluzzo, our civil litigators have assisted unions, individual employees, associations, professionals, pension plans, investors, benefit trust funds and other organizations in advancing their interests through a range of creative and important litigation in the courts.

Our lawyers also advise individual non-unionized employees at every stage of the employment relationship: from reviewing an offer of employment to wrongful dismissal. We represent employees from all walks of life, including the financial services industry, manufacturing, public service, the health and education sectors.

Our lawyers have experience negotiating with and litigating against major boards, utility companies, non-profit organizations and IT firms. Our employment law practise spans the country and is multi-national: we represent people with employment law issues connected to Canada working around the World. 

Our employment advice and advocacy includes:

  • advising and litigating wrongful dismissal and constructive dismissal claims, including class actions;
  • enforcing Ontario and Federal legislation on collective bargaining, employment standards, human rights, occupational health and safety, workers compensation;
  • advising on human rights compliance, including pay and employment equity plans for workplaces and alternative dispute resolution measures;
  • reviewing and negotiating severance "packages" on termination;
  • preparing and negotiating employment contracts;
  • advising employees on workplace obligations including confidentiality and fiduciary obligations;
  • defending employees against ex-employers alleging breach of restrictive covenants, such as non-compete and non-solicitation clauses;
  • acting for unions in strike and lockout injunction litigation;
  • representing employees and unions in bankruptcy and insolvency trusteeship proceedings; and
  • prosecuting litigation against government entities that abuse their authority.

Notable representations include:

  • Michela v. St. Thomas of Villanova Catholic School, which involved three teachers' wrongful dismissal claims. The school argued that its financial circumstances should be considered when determining reasonable notice. The Court of Appeal disagreed, holding that an employer's financial circumstances are not relevant to the determination of reasonable notice. Michela is now one of the leading wrongful dismissal decisions in Canada, and appears to have ended a thirty-year debate as to whether an employer's financial picture is relevant in wrongful dismissal cases.
  • Oliveira v. Aviva Canada Inc., which is the first Canadian case to consider an insurer's obligations in the face of ever-increasing attempts to hold employees liable for privacy breaches, in which the Firm represented a nurse who had been sued by a patient for alleged breaches of privacy in the workplace. The nurse sought coverage and legal defence from her insurer, which refused. The Superior Court held that the insurer was obligated to defend the claim. The Court of Appeal agreed.
  • Horne v. Queen Elizabeth II Health Sciences Centre, in which Dr. Gabrielle Horne, a cardiologist and research scientist, alleged that the hospital, among others, wrongfully varied her privileges on an emergency basis, causing substantial damage to her reputation and her career as a researcher.  After an eight-week jury trial, the jury found that the hospital had acted in bad faith and awarded Dr. Horne $1.4 million in reputation damages. The Nova Scotia Court of Appeal upheld the jury's finding of bad faith, but reduced the damages award, which remains the largest award of reputation damages in Canada outside for a non-defamation claim.
  • McMichael v The New Zealand & Australian Lamb Company, in which the Court awarded 22 months' notice to a senior executive with 12 years' service. This decision is notable for the complex cross-border issues raised, as the plaintiff was employed by a US company headquartered in Connecticut, was working in California, but had an employment agreement governed by Ontario law.
  • Legg v. Simcoe Muskoka Catholic District School Board, in which the Court of Appeal for Ontario considered whether an indemnification clause in an employee agreement was enforceable against the employer in connection with legal fees incurred as a result of an internal investigation. Cavalluzzo won a significant victory for Ms. Legg in one of the only reported decisions in Canada concerning these clauses.
  • Partridge v. Botony Dental Corporation, in which the Court of Appeal considered whether the employer had wrongfully dissed our client, a dental hygienist, when it refused to return her to her original position upon returning from maternity leave, deliberately increased her work to conflict with her child care obligations and then purported to terminate her employment for cause. The Court of Appeal agreed with the Superior Court's decision that the employer had no evidence to support its allegations of cause and award of 12 months' reasonable notice damages and human rights damages.
  • Fioravanti v. OLG, in which Cavalluzzo acted for Ontario Lottery and Gaming Corporation's former General Counsel, and one of its most senior executives.  Cavalluzzo was entirely successful on the question of OLG's liability to this executive concerning his exit agreement with the company.

Non-unionized employee? Click here

Ongoing Class Actions

Last Modified: 5 April 2022

Cineflix Class Action

A class action lawsuit was recently settled between Cineflix and factual TV workers. The settlement provides compensation to most Cineflix workers who...
Last Modified: 27 July 2021

Enbridge Pension Plan Class Action

The class action alleges that Enbridge was required to give its employees “credited service” when its employees take a maternity or parent...
Last Modified: 20 May 2021

Blyth Academy Class Action

CASE SETTLED – MATTER COMPLETED In October 2017, Cavalluzzo LLP launched a class action against Blyth Academy on behalf of its teachers. The cla...
Last Modified: 18 February 2021

CTS of Canada Class Action

Notice of Proposed Class Action Settlement A settlement agreement has been reached between CTS and the Representative Plaintiffs, Claudette Wood, John...
Last Modified: 24 February 2020

Factual Television Class Action

Class action lawsuits are being contemplated against factual television producers.   If you work or worked for Cineflix, Insight Productions, Boa...

Completed Class Actions

Last Modified: 21 December 2018

Ontario Government Retiree Benefits Case

Our firm commenced an action against the Ontario government with respect to its decision to reduce the health, dental and other benefits of approximat...
Last Modified: 21 December 2018

Krones Machinery Co. Ltd.

This is an action which was initiated with respect to the closure of this manufacturing facility in Brampton, Ontario.
Last Modified: 21 December 2018

Viskase Companies Inc. and Viskase Canada Inc.

A settlement was reached reinstating paid life insurance coverage and compensating certain class members for the loss of their other paid benefits.
Last Modified: 21 December 2018

North Shore Catholic District School Board

When mutual insurance companies “demutualized” several years ago, a number of employers received substantial benefits as a result of the g...
Last Modified: 21 December 2018

Johnson Controls Inc.

This action was commenced on April 16, 2010 after Johnson Controls Inc. announced that it was closing its manufacturing plant in Orangeville, Ontario ...
Last Modified: 21 December 2018

Ontario Nurses' Association CCAC Pension Action

For current and former ONA members who worked for municipalities or home care services between 1996-1998, whether you were an ONA member or not when y...

Related Cases

Case/
13 March 2019

Cormier v. 1772887 Ontario Limited

In Cormier v. 1772887 Ontario Limited, Christopher Perri and Alex St. John represented Kelly Cormier in a wrongful dismissal action against a com...
Case/
2 January 2019

Heller v. Uber Technologies

Cavalluzzo LLP acted for David Heller in Heller v. Uber Technologies.
Case/
27 November 2018

Kranjcec v. Ontario

Class action regarding retiree benefits.
Case/
27 November 2018

Omers Sponsors Corporation v. Omers Administration Corporation

Omers Sponsors Corporation v. Omers Administration Corporation, 2008 CanLII 3970 (ON SC). The Applicant OMERS Sponsors Corporation (“SC”) ...
Case/
27 November 2018

Slansky v. Canada

Slansky v. Canada (Attorney General), 2011 FC 1467 This is an appeal pursuant to Rule 51 of the Federal Courts Rules, SOR/98-106 [Rules] of a decision...

Related Resources

News/22 June 2022

"Inappropriate Workplace Behaviour Dangerous to your Career’"

In today's Legal Matters, Jeff Andrew discusses the dangers of inappropriate workplace behaviour suc...
News/16 June 2022

Stephen Moreau Quoted in Law Times and The Lawyer's Daily

Stephen Moreau is quoted today in both The Law Times and The Lawyers Daily, commenting on the Ontari...
News/8 June 2022

ONCA Overturns Rahman v Cannon Design Architecture Inc

ONCA Overturns Rahman v Cannon Design Architecture Inc, Proving that Employee's Level of Sophisticat...
Event/3 June 2022

Jackie Esmonde represents the CCLA at today’s roundtable discussion hosted by the federal Employment Equity Task Force

Jackie Esmonde represents the Canadian Civil Liberties Association (CCLA) at a roundtable discussion...
Blog/17 December 2021

Working for Workers Act, 2021

Ontario Passes Legislation Affecting Workers’ Rights

Cavalluzzo LLP lawyers share their thoughts on the Working for Workers Act, 2021, which received Royal Assent on December 2, 2021. Reforms affecting O...
Blog/17 December 2021

Working for Workers Act, 2021

Ontario Passes Legislation Affecting Workers’ Rights

Cavalluzzo LLP lawyers share their thoughts on the Working for Workers Act, 2021, which received Royal Assent on December 2, 2021. Reforms affecting O...
Blog/8 November 2021

Bill 27: Working for Workers Act, 2021

Ontario Introduces Legislation Affecting Workers’ Rights

Cavalluzzo LLP lawyers share their thoughts on Bill 27, Working for Workers Act, 2021. This Bill proposes several changes that will impact Ontario wor...
Blog/20 October 2021

Reflections: Labour, Human and Civil Rights

Darshan Singh Sangha: Transforming early exposure to workplace hardship into activism against workplace race discrimination and toward unifying workers to mobilize for improved and equitable working conditions for all

Sheilagh Turkington dives into the history of Darshan Singh Sangha, and his national advocacy for the sawmill workers within the Sikh community, and h...
News/22 June 2022

"Inappropriate Workplace Behaviour Dangerous to your Career’"

In today's Legal Matters, Jeff Andrew discusses the dangers of inappropriate workplace behaviour such as sexualized banter or any form of non-consensu...
News/16 June 2022

Stephen Moreau Quoted in Law Times and The Lawyer's Daily

Moreau discusses his client's recent victory in Rahman v Cannon Design Architecture Inc

Stephen Moreau is quoted today in both The Law Times and The Lawyers Daily, commenting on the Ontario Court of Appeal's recent decision in Rahman v Ca...
News/8 June 2022

ONCA Overturns Rahman v Cannon Design Architecture Inc

Employee's Level of Sophistication Has No Bearing on Enforceability of Termination Clause

ONCA Overturns Rahman v Cannon Design Architecture Inc, Proving that Employee's Level of Sophistication Has No Bearing on Enforceability of Terminatio...
News/24 May 2022

How Uber Got Almost Everything It Wanted in Ontario's Working for Workers Act

Ryan White discusses how Bill 88 negatively impacts gig workers while helping employers

Cavalluzzo's Ryan White comments in today's Globe and Mail article, "How Uber Almost Got Everything it Wanted in Ontario's Working for Workers Act". R...
News/11 April 2022

"Unions Careful when it comes to Duty of Fair Representation"

Jeff Andrew discusses a union’s responsibility to protect the collective interests of all members, not necessarily just an individual’s rights

In today's Legal Matters, Jeff Andrew discusses a union’s responsibility to protect the collective interests of all members, not necessarily just an i...
News/7 April 2022

Cineflix Settlement Called a "Win-Win for Workers"

Playback Online and the Hollywood Reporter publish articles regarding this class action settlement

Cineflix settlement called a "win-win" for workers. Playback Online and the Hollywood Reporter publish articles regarding this class action settlement...
Event/Jun 3, 2022

Jackie Esmonde represents the CCLA at today’s roundtable discussion hosted by the federal Employment Equity Task Force

Jackie Esmonde represents the Canadian Civil Liberties Association (CCLA) at a roundtable discussion hosted by the federal Employment Equity Task Forc...
Event/Apr 22, 2021

Stephen Moreau Speaks on Radio Canada

Stephen Moreau speaks this morning on Radio-Canada’s “L'ABC des congés de maladie en Ontario”, describing the various paid an...
Event/Oct 24, 2019 - Oct 17, 2019

Sheilagh Turkington Speaks at Osgoode's Advanced Issues in Special Education Conference

Sheilagh Turkington is a faculty member at Osgoode Hall’s 14th Annual Program on Advanced Issues in Special Education conference. She will be sp...
Event/Oct 29, 2019

Stephen Moreau Speaks at the Ontario Bar Association Conference on "Ending the Employment Relationship"

Stephen is speaking at the Ontario Bar Association on ensuring that the employment contract has appropriate and enforceable termination provisions, av...
Event/Nov 1, 2019

Stephen Moreau and Chris Perri Speak at 20th Annual Employment Law Summit

Stephen Moreau and Chris Perri speak at  the Law Society of Ontario's 20th Annual Employment Law Summit. They will be speaking on the issue of so...
Event/Oct 2, 2019

Elichai Shaffir Speaks at Lancaster House Training Session on Handling Personal Health Information

Elichai Shaffir speaks at Lancaster House's Skills Training Session: "Handling Personal Health Information: An In-Depth Training Session for Employers...
Publication/13 February 2018

Summary of Bill 148 - "Fair Workplaces, Better Jobs Act, 2017 Brings Major Changes to Ontario's Labour and Employment Laws"

Please note that new legislation has been introduced, which will repeal many of these reforms.  Please see the summary at this link. A summary of...
Publication/29 November 2013

The Year in Review in Labour and Employment Law

2013 was another eventful year on the labour and employment law fronts. The workplace continues to be the locus of much litigation before courts and t...
Publication/1 January 2013

Bisnar, Danielle & McIntyre, Elizabeth. “Lessons for Litigators from ONA v. Chatham-Kent: A Union Perspective”, (2013) 17 Canadian Labour & Employment Law Journal 225

Bisnar, Danielle & McIntyre, Elizabeth. “Lessons for Litigators from ONA v. Chatham-Kent: A Union Perspective”, (2013) 17 Canadian Lab...
Publication/16 April 2006

Pregnant Women have a Number of Ways to Claim Job Rights, but are they Effective?

Anecdotal evidence suggests that, in spite of the job protection provided by the Employment Standards Act (ESA), women are increasingly being dismisse...
Publication/2 June 2005

Severance Pay & Valuing Disabled Employees' Past Contributions and Investments: O.N.A. v. Mount Sinai Hospitals

Employment standards legislation has proven largely immune to Charter scrutiny. Various challenges to this minimum standards legislation, such as a s....
Publication/1 March 2004

Annotated Executive Employment Agreement

The employment relationship is fundamentally one of contract. While many employment relationships are based on nothing more than a handshake, it is in...