Court of Appeal Rules in Favour of CUPW Casual Workers

News/
20 June 2019
Share
Share with your friends and colleagues
Pick one or more destinations:

On June 11, 2019, the Ontario Court of Appeal ruled in favour of CUPW casual workers in a decision arising from a grievance of a casual postal worker’s dismissal for his alleged failure to be reasonably available for work assignments.  CUPW was successful at the grievance arbitration in arguing that Canada Post’s reliance on an average acceptance rate benchmark to justify terminating the grievor’s employment was unreasonable.  The arbitrator reinstated the grievor, finding that Canada Post should have considered the grievor’s actual number of shifts accepted and that his refusal to accept certain shifts caused the company no prejudice.  On judicial review of the arbitration award, the Divisional Court upheld the award in part.  Canada Post appealed. 

The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal, holding that the arbitrator did not err in considering factors other than the grievor’s relative acceptance rate to determine the reasonableness of his availability.  The Court explained that arbitrators should perform a contextual analysis to determine the reasonableness of availability, which can include the following factors: the number of shifts offered, the manner of the offers, the total number of shifts and hours worked and the nature of operations.  The Court noted that personal circumstances, such as an employee’s reasons for declining shifts, may also be considered in the analysis.

Congratulations to CUPW, who was represented by Paul Cavalluzzo and Adrienne Telford, on this excellent outcome.

A copy of the Court of Appeal’s decision can be found here.

Recent News

News/27 May 2025

Revisiting the Universal Basic Income Pilot Project: Stephen Moreau Interviewed by Global News

"We Want Ontario to Keep Their Promise"

Stephen Moreau was interviewed by Focus Ontario: Global News outlining the class action lawsuit against the government over the cancelled universal ba... Read More
News/19 March 2025

Jackie Esmonde Quoted in Law360 Article Regarding Recent Ontario Court of Appeal Decision

Cavalluzzo LLP represented intervenor group in constitutional challenge regarding Ontario Place

Jackie Esmonde Quoted in Law360 Article Regarding Recent Ontario Court of Appeal Decision. Cavalluzzo LLP represented intervenor group in constitution... Read More
News/28 February 2025

Ryan White Quoted in Toronto Star Article

Weighing in on Ontario’s proposed gig worker laws

Ryan White was recently quoted in a Toronto Star article exploring whether Ontario should follow British Columbia’s lead in implementing minimum wage ... Read More